Developer criticizes authorities for delays surrounding the demolition at Wenceslas Square

Publisher
ČTK
05.12.2012 22:05
Czech Republic

Prague

Prague - The developer who wants to tear down an old building in the center of Prague and build a new one in its place criticizes Czech authorities for not yet definitively deciding whether the structure is or is not a cultural monument. This affects the possibility of starting the demolition of this building on the corner of Wenceslas Square and Opletalova Street. The demolition plan has faced criticism from the public and experts alike, and about 50 people protested against it today in front of the Ministry of Culture, called by the association Občanský monitoring.
    
The previous city council allowed the current building to be demolished, and the decision was later confirmed by the former Minister of Culture Jiří Besser (TOP 09 and STAN). However, after criticism from various quarters, the case will now undergo new deliberations - the spokesman for the Ministry of Culture, Markéta Ševčíková, told the demonstrators that Minister Alena Hanáková (TOP 09 and STAN) today signed a decision on a review process. "This should take a maximum of two months. During the process, the building is protected, so the owner cannot dispose of it," the spokesperson added.
     According to the protest organizer Vítězslav Praksa, the issue is not just about the building itself, but the square as a whole, as it is a UNESCO heritage zone. "Demolition is absolutely undesirable there," he stated. The gathering was also attended by a quartet of men dressed as monkeys holding signs that read Returners, Death to Prague, and Stop Progress. According to the demonstrators, these were people paid by the building's owner, which is the subject of the dispute. The men, however, did not respond to questions and refused to speak into the microphone.
     For the company Flow East, which wants to build on Wenceslas Square, the long-term uncertainty in doing business is unacceptable according to its statement. Chairman James Woolf stated in today’s press release that the question arises whether this is not an abuse of power. Woolf writes, among other things, that today he would have to advise foreign investors considering doing business in the Czech Republic to invest elsewhere.
     "We have done everything to present our plans, cooperate with our partners and the public, inform key stakeholders about our vision, and we have always fulfilled our obligations. The Czech Republic has never been a country where progress and change were ignored and rejected, and we hope that this will not happen in this case either," he states. He believes that "the best intentions" of Flow East have been rejected "only due to a minority of unelected and irresponsible extremists who want to keep Prague in times of darkness." In addition to opposition to the demolition of the current building, public objections also concern the design of the building that is supposed to replace it. Former President Václav Havel has also joined these objections in the past.
     The so-called appeals commission recommended a new assessment of the case to the minister. The process is led by the Minister herself, with assistance from the commission, and she can also request additional independent expert opinions. The review mainly concerns the decision of the cultural heritage department of the Ministry of Culture, which decided in September that the building would not be declared a cultural monument. It did so despite admitting the building's indisputable qualities and its important place in the Prague Heritage Reserve in its reasoning. However, its staff did not declare the building a monument because they did not want the "consequences of serious legal flaws" in the city heritage officials' statements to "heal the overvaluation of the qualities of the disputed building."
     The city’s heritage department allowed the building to be demolished. Although experts from the ministry labeled its stance as illegal and canceled it, it was only after the legal deadline. The then-Minister Besser therefore canceled his heritage officials' decision because the building's owner had counted on the city council's verdict for half a year, and his ministerial cancellation could reportedly jeopardize the investment.
     Some experts protested against the plan to replace the early 20th-century building with a large new construction already following the announcement of the proposal last year. They pointed out that the Minister of Culture should rather defend the interests of the state in the area of heritage care rather than those of a private investor.
The English translation is powered by AI tool. Switch to Czech to view the original text source.
3 comments
add comment
Subject
Author
Date
James Woolf
takyarchitekt
06.12.12 01:23
>> takyarchitekt
T. Fiala
06.12.12 08:35
Woolf je demagog
Milan Škobrtal
06.12.12 09:57
show all comments

Related articles

0 03.08.2016 | Prague is against the demolition of Kozák's house, wants to know the project
0 11.02.2015 | The ministry is against the demolition of the house on Wenceslas Square
0 10.06.2014 | The magistrate canceled the decision on the demolition of the house on Wenceslas Square
0 28.11.2013 | The NKÚ will not address the case of the demolition of the house on Wenceslas Square
0 28.10.2013 | The house on Opletalova Street was leveled to the ground
3 26.10.2013 | About a third of the former printery in Opletalova has already been demolished
0 21.10.2013 | Due to the building on the corner of Wenceslas Square, the office is dealing with four appeals
0 17.10.2013 | The appeal could delay the construction of the house in Wenceslas Square by several years
0 05.10.2013 | Senators will reevaluate the demolition of the house on Wenceslas Square
0 25.09.2013 | The building authority approved the demolition of the house at the corner of Wenceslas Square
0 19.09.2013 | Prague has appealed against the construction of a building on Wenceslas Square
0 16.09.2013 | Investor obtained a zoning decision for construction at the corner of Václavák
0 22.08.2013 | The application for the demolition of the house on Wenceslas Square is already with the authorities
0 30.07.2013 | Hamster criticizes the magistrate for the demolition at Wenceslas Square
0 04.07.2013 | The Institute of Art History is against the demolition of the building on Wenceslas Square
0 03.07.2013 | <div>The house on the corner of Wenceslas Square is not a monument; it will be demolished.</div>
2 18.06.2013 | MK has been deciding on the protection of the house on Wenceslas Square for over half a year
0 30.04.2013 | The torso of the former print shop in Opletalova Street is skewed
0 17.12.2012 | The owner of the corner house on Opletalova Street criticizes the steps of the Ministry of Culture
0 04.12.2012 | The ministry is once again dealing with the house at Wenceslas Square
0 14.11.2012 | Experts again want the house on Wenceslas Square to be a monument
0 09.11.2012 | Experts: Demolishing the house on Wenceslas Square will violate the law
0 06.11.2012 | The commission will evaluate the decision regarding the house on Wenceslas Square
4 29.10.2012 | <div>The house on Wenceslas Square is not a monument, it can be renovated.</div>
0 20.09.2012 | The fate of the house on Wenceslas Square still depends on the decision of the MK
0 16.03.2012 | The ministry will no longer deal with the house on Václavské náměstí
12 15.03.2012 | Experts proposed to declare the house on Wenceslas Square as a monument
0 06.01.2012 | The Constitutional Court rejected the complaint against Besser's stance on the disputed demolition
0 14.12.2011 | Senate: The ministry should reassess interventions in monuments in Prague
0 08.12.2011 | The Senate will address the demolition of the building at Wenceslas Square next week
0 27.09.2011 | The ministry will not renew the proceedings regarding the demolition of the house on "Václavák"
21 23.09.2011 | Historics: The plan to demolish the house in Wenceslas Square is barbaric
0 21.09.2011 | Investor reduced the height of the planned new building on Wenceslas Square
0 04.08.2011 | TOP 09 will be dealing with the actions of Minister Besser next week
1 03.08.2011 | The Senate committee proposed a review of the demolition of the building at Wenceslas Square
0 19.07.2011 | Experts for the restoration of management in the demolition of a house on Wenceslas Square
0 08.07.2011 | New construction on Wenceslas Square will not be assessed within the EIA
6 07.06.2011 | People protested against the demolition of the house in Wenceslas Square
0 02.06.2011 | The Club for Old Prague called a protest against the demolition of the house near Jalta
0 02.06.2011 | Besser defends the demolition of the Art Nouveau building in Wenceslas Square
33 26.05.2011 | The Minister of Culture Besser decided on the demolition of a house in the center of Prague
0 03.02.2011 | The Ministry rejected the proposal for a new building in Wenceslas Square
0 03.12.2010 | Inspection: Approval for the demolition of the house in the center of Prague is illegal
14 11.11.2010 | Press Release from the Club for Old Prague regarding the intention to demolish the building No. 1601-II on the corner of Wenceslas Square and Opletalova Street
18 11.11.2010 | The house at the corner of Wenceslas Square and Opletalova is probably going to be demolished