The relocation of the train station means the devastation of historically protected buildings

Source
Nádraží v centru
Publisher
Tisková zpráva
21.08.2006 20:45

Brno – In connection with the reconstruction of the Brno railway junction with the station relocated to a different position, part of two protected buildings in the city slaughterhouse area on Masná and Porážka streets is to be demolished. The construction of the Přerov line on an embankment section of the Komárovská connector will directly affect valuable cultural monuments, Masná burza and the Municipal Slaughterhouse halls by architect Bohuslav Fuchs from the 1930s. However, in the event of modernizing the junction with the station in the center, there would be no interference with either monument.

So far, the city council has not presented to the Brno public the fact that due to the relocation of the station, partial demolitions of two very significant architectural cultural monuments will occur. The functionalist building Masná burza (Masná 34) will have its northern wing demolished, and even after that, the track will run at the level of its second floor in close proximity to the rest of the structure. The original administrative function of the building will subsequently be excluded. The embankment will also cut through the roof of the large hall of the Municipal Slaughterhouse, thereby significantly disrupting its cultural-historical value.
The Municipal Slaughterhouse is owned by the city through Brněnské komunikaci a.s. Masná burza has a private owner, the Prague company PESTR spol s r.o. This company has invested tens of millions into the modernization of the building in recent years. Currently, the Railway and Transport Administration s.o., one of the investors in the reconstruction of the railway junction, is negotiating with this company about the purchase of Masná burza with funds from the project budget. There is also consideration of "de-classifying" the previously protected buildings.
The construction of a concrete railway embankment across the area of the municipal slaughterhouse will also disrupt the genius loci of this area, which has not been very well known to the public until now. After the demolition of the majority of buildings in the former industrial area Vaňkovka, the destruction of the oldest Brno apartment building U sedmi švábů, and the devastation of Velký Špalíček in previous years, the city is losing another part of its cultural history.
The Heritage Conservation Department of the City of Brno stated in its binding opinion from December 9, 2005, that “it considers the proposed solution of the railway body's intersection with the slaughterhouse hall to be a solution lacking respect for the values of the protected area of the former slaughterhouse and believes that it is one, but not the only, possible variant of integrating the cultural monument into new contexts.” Svatopluk Bartík from the Nádraží v centru coalition says: “Despite the evidently critical stance towards this variant, the officials ultimately issued consent to the devastation of cultural monuments. According to us, this happened under political pressure related to the entire station relocation project.”
The English translation is powered by AI tool. Switch to Czech to view the original text source.
5 comments
add comment
Subject
Author
Date
Surrealistický urbanismus
Jan Kratochvíl
21.08.06 09:45
nevim, jak Brnaci posuzuji svuj urbanismus
Jan Sommer
22.08.06 08:52
smutná skutečnost
JirkaV
22.08.06 09:44
No a co
Petr Machač
22.08.06 09:49
Re: No a co
Pietro
22.08.06 12:22
show all comments

Related articles

1 13.11.2016 | Brno station is awaiting reconstruction costing a quarter of a billion
0 24.05.2016 | Brno selected three best studies for the option of a relocated train station
6 19.12.2015 | In the urban planning competition for the Brno South Center, there are 57 proposals
1 15.12.2015 | Alliance Referendum 2016 launched a campaign for the location of the train station in Brno
1 07.09.2015 | Green and Žít Brno do not like the content of the website about the reconstruction of the railway station
2 04.09.2015 | Brno will gradually publish information about the reconstruction of the station
0 03.06.2015 | ÚOHS suspended the proceedings regarding the study on the renovation of the train station in Brno
0 22.04.2015 | SŽDC excluded Helika from the tender for the study on the Brno train station
1 15.04.2015 | Plicka: Let a two-round competition decide about the Brno train station
1 14.04.2015 | Select the author of the study for the train station in Brno may not be completed on time
2 03.03.2015 | Brno will announce a competition for the design of the Southern Center with a train station under Petrov
0 27.02.2015 | The Brno main station forecourt will start being renovated this weekend
0 07.02.2015 | The court rejected the lawsuits of Kotzian, ODS, and ČSSD regarding the timing of the referendum
0 19.12.2014 | Spolek Brno+ wants to repeal the resolution of the councilors regarding the relocation of the train station
1 26.11.2014 | Underka considers the referendum approved in two years to be unfortunate
1 25.11.2014 | The referendum about the station is set to take place in Brno with the regional elections
0 10.11.2014 | SŽDC will compare in detail the variants of the new Brno station
0 07.10.2014 | Brno has committed to purchasing land near Zvonařka for the construction of a train station
0 26.08.2014 | The Brno City Hall has suspended the proceedings regarding the train station
9 22.08.2014 | Activists sue the Brno magistrate over the train station petition
1 19.05.2014 | Brno activists reject both options for the new train station
7 26.03.2014 | Brno councilors want to keep the station in its displaced position
0 07.02.2014 | Experts today presented two variants of the station in Brno
2 17.01.2014 | Activists will launch a campaign for a second referendum on the train station in Brno
1 30.10.2013 | Activists have once again challenged the zoning decision at the station in Brno
0 13.06.2012 | Opponents of the relocation of the Brno train station will send a statement to Brussels
0 05.03.2012 | Brno has its first official document that admits to a train station in the center
0 27.02.2012 | The councilor of the South Moravian Region stood up for the relocation of the train station in Brno
0 09.02.2012 | Czech Railways do not want to sell the land near the train station in Brno for now
2 13.12.2011 | Young architects have designed a new look for the train station in the center of Brno
1 24.10.2011 | The Ministry of Culture does not agree with the relocation of the Brno train station
0 26.05.2011 | Mayor: The relocation of the train station in Brno will have a land use decision this year
2 07.09.2009 | The Lidovci want to change the project for the reconstruction of the Brno railway